The Lapeer County EMS (LCEMS) millage will be up for a vote on the Primary Ballot on August 6 as well as available for early voting on July 27. If passed, it would include a renewal of the 2016 millage for an additional six years and would also include an increase of 33.3 percent. The upcoming vote has residents divided on the issue, as some question the handling of resources.
Kevin Knisely, a Lapeer County Commissioner, told the Tribune, “We need emergency medical service, it is absolutely essential. However, we can do better in this area and it is imperative that everyone is able to make an informed decision.” One of the focal points surrounding the proposal is how voters need to have their voices heard and how the timeline of when it is being presented may hinder that. “Historically, primary elections have a lower turnout than general elections, which is why in order to truly allow the voters to weigh in on the issue, it should have be presented on the November ballot instead,” Knisely said.
Those opposed to the millage are stating that one of the main concerns is how LCEMS is currently handling funds, citing how co-pays and deductibles have been waived for those in Lapeer County. In 2023, there was $853,000 in waived co-pays and deductibles, a policy by LCEMS that is being scrutinized due to having not been voted on by the public when they approved the previous millage. In addition, there is also controversy over how LCEMS paid over $234,000 in legal expenses that same year in a lawsuit against Lapeer County Medical Control Authority.
“The poor mismanagement of funds is placing an undue burden on taxpayers to cover these services, some of whom may not ever use the service themselves. I ran for office because I wanted to make a difference on a local level and so I feel compelled to advocate for the taxpayers, who right now have some serious concerns.” Knisely stated.
Russ Adams, the Executive Director for LCEMS spoke with the Tribune in response to the allegations he has seen online, “There are private companies who claim that they can provide the same services for cheap or free. However, even if they were to be successful there would be an even greater cost to the community in a different form. If someone says that they have the ability to do something which normally costs about 5 million dollars, for free, it should be questioned.”
Adams stated that it costs on average $500,000-$600,000 per unit for wages alone and that LCEMS normally has seven units. He explained that there are companies which use data programs to determine when they should have more units available. “Emergencies occur at random, and the reason why we have opposite business models is because LCEMS strives to ensure that all calls are responded to with the same urgency and care; we aim to be available at your time of need.” said Adams.
Additionally, he told the Tribune that there are some misconceptions being spoken in regard to the numbers beings stated as losses. He explained how on average, a call would result in a $324 reimbursement but that not every call they respond to results in an emergency that can be billed to insurance. These situations make the difference between what would have been claimed and the amounts waived significantly smaller. He also stated that they provide other services at no cost to the community such as having units be present at Lapeer Days and the Eastern Michigan Fair.
“Something to understand is that not all residents can afford their copay or deductible. Waiving those fees is a welcome relief. We look at it as the tax on every parcel of property has paid the wages of our organization-you should not be charged again out of pocket to use it.” Adams concluded.
Jennifer VanDam, a Lapeer County resident, posted her concerns on the Friends of Lapeer County Taxpayers Facebook page, “For me, the issue isn’t medical care, the issue is where government dependency is leading us as a nation…we are not just talking about $100 per year for a millage. We are talking about $100 per year for only one of the millages on our property tax bills.” VanDam went on to say that she has thirteen total items that she is paying for with her property taxes and that while some may consider those to be minimal amounts; they are fees that are not her choice to pay, that other people are making the choices for her.
Both those in favor and those opposed to the LCEMS proposal agree that this is an important decision and that every resident’s voice needs to be heard; the public is urged to show up and vote on the issue. More information on the upcoming election and millage renewal can be found on the lapeercountymi.gov website.