As we approach election day on November 5th, most of the national polls reveal a very tight race. The latest New York Times poll shows that Vice President Kamala Harris has a two-point lead on former president Donald Trump, which is well within the margin of error. In Michigan, the polls are a dead heat, which some might find surprising considering Michigan is part of the “blue wall” that encompasses the rust belt.
Since 1992, this blue wall has consistently been a boon for Democrats. States that include Michigan, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Pennsylvania, and Illinois have remained solidly blue. That was until the 2016 election when Trump broke down the blue wall and flipped Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin red, ultimately winning him the election. This was a surprise to many, considering a Republican had not won the general election in those states since the 1980s. Pennsylvania was the slight exception, last voting Republican back in 1992.
Plenty of blame went around for Trump’s victory, which happened by the smallest of margins. In the end, voter turnout was down in 2016 amongst black and young voters, just enough to turn historically blue states red, even if it was just for a single election. By the time the 2020 election rolled around, the blue wall has been rebuilt in support of Joe Biden who won after a historic turnout, securing more votes than any other presidential candidate in U.S. history.
In 2024, some polls hint the blue wall could be on the verge of crumbling again. Harris and Trump are dead even in Michigan, which means without a large Democrat turnout, the state could flip back red. One area of concern for the Democrats is that Michigan has a large Arab population. The Biden/Harris administration has received criticism from Arab Americans on how it has handled the Gaza/Israel conflict. As the U.S. continues to support Israel under Biden, Arab Americans have threated to either sit out of this election or throw their support behind Jill Stein, who is a nominee for the Green Party.
While this protest might not seem like a huge deal, it can swing the tide in a deadlocked Michigan, which has the largest population of Arabs of any state by a wide margin. Four percent of Michiganders are of Arab descentand havemostly supported Democrats in general elections.If that four percent decide not to vote, or decide to vote for the former president, the implications are massive. Trump could once again shatter the blue wall in 2024.
Arab American voters are not alone in separating themselves from the Democrat party. Union Teamsters, who have supported a Democrat for president since 1996, came out in September and said they will not endorse a candidate. Teamsters President Sean O’Brien said in a statement:
“Unfortunately, neither major candidate was able to make serious commitments to our union to ensure the interests of working people are always put before Big Business.” Trump considered it a “great honor” that the Teamsters did not endorse his opponent.
Among the 1.3 million members within the Teamsters, internal polling found that more members support Trump over Harris, but theirleader is taking a more neutral approach. O’Brien hopes the lack of endorsement will encourage future candidates to do more to earn their support. “If people want the support of the most powerful union in North America, whether you’re a Democrat or Republican, start doing some things to support our members,” O’Brien said.
Ultimately, what will help or hurt Harris’ chances of winning the election will be how the electorate views her on a personal level. Hillary Clinton was not a popular candidate back in 2016, so the enthusiasm in voting for her waned. Trump won Michigan by less than 12,000 votes. Despite the Arab American turnout or how the union members vote, Harris has a chance to overcome these obstacles if the enthusiasm from other voting blocks is on her side.
The other question is if enthusiasm has waned for Trump. Trump has failed to secure the popular vote on either election he’s run for, but it does not always matter. Elections are not won or lost on popularity. It would not appear as if enthusiasm has waned for the Republican candidate, but we will not know that until November 5th. Harris is trying her best to overcome what will be a difficult election with an onslaught of attack ads throughout the local and national media.
Whatever happens in Michigan, the state’s 15 electoral votes are up for grabs, and it is not a done deal for either candidate. Michigan remains firmly in the toss-up category, as well as Wisconsin and Pennsylvania. The traditional blue wall is looking increasingly purple and whoever wins Michigan could very well win the election.